When I was in grade school, I believe it was seventh grade to be exact, I remember being introduced to the vocabulary term propaganda. I can remember looking at pictures in my social studies text book of old WWI and WWII posters, displaying various images and slogans designed to inspire people to enlist in America’s military. Most of you are probably familiar with the image of Uncle Sam, with his white hair and stars and stripes top hat, pointing his finger and claiming the he wants YOU, for the U.S. Army. While that particular poster was originally created for the war of 1812, it was used extensively through out both world wars and it’s familiarity has continued into modern times. It is known to be a prime example of what is referred to as American propaganda.
The definition of propaganda, as stated by the Merriam-Webster dictionary, is: 1: the spreading of ideas, information, or rumor for the purpose of helping or injuring an institution, a cause, or a person 2: ideas, facts, or allegations spread deliberately to further one’s cause or to damage an opposing cause; also : a public action having such an effect.
Now for the reason why I bring this up. The purpose of this blog is simply to bring attention to what I believe to be the most successful work of propaganda currently in use by the American government, media, and it’s society as a whole.
It is a simple, one sentence slogan that goes as follows: Support Our Troops.
Political analyst Noam Chomsky made a good point when criticizing the slogan, saying, “the point of public relations slogans like “Support Our Troops” is that they don’t mean anything. That’s the whole point of good propaganda. You want to create a slogan that nobody is going to be against and I suppose everybody will be for, because nobody knows what it means, because it doesn’t mean anything. But its crucial value is that it diverts your attention from a question that does mean something…do you support our policy? And that’s the one you’re not allowed to talk about.”
Well, I’m talking about it.
Can you think of a more successful means of gathering support of the American people for their government’s actions than what this one little sentence has done over the past decade? Since it was first introduced around the time of the Gulf war, this catchy slogan has spread to literally everywhere you go. It’s on your local news, it’s in your favorite television shows, on bumper stickers, and even in churches. And because of this, it has gotten so popular that it is no longer just just spread by those who are actually in support of the country’s military. Whether people actually think about the slogan or not, they go along with it as “the right thing to do,” since it has become so socially acceptable that it seems as if no one, barring an “ alleged terrorist,” could possibly be so morally reprehensible as to disagree with such a statement.
Well, I have a problem with this. If you haven’t already guessed, I do not support America’s role in the middle east. But that is not what this blog is about. What has motivated me to write this is that as a citizen of America it seems that I should be expected to support this country’s military, without question. “Supporting the troops” has become such a common slogan, that it seems as if no one even considers the fact that it may be offensive to others. It is as if no matter who you are or where you are from, if you are in this country it goes without saying that you will automatically go along with supporting it’s military.
I was recently on a plane with a few men wearing the military fatigues when I heard the flight attendant come on over the intercom announcing that they were on their way back from Iraq, and asked that “everybody give these heroes a big round of applause!” I did not clap. I did not know these people, and had absolutely nothing against them personally. However, that does not mean I should be expected to support what it is they are choosing to do with their lives. Because I don’t.
I would like to point out the observation that so many in this country seem to miss. They are not “our” troops. The military is not under our control. The American people do not vote on the actions that the military takes. They are the American government’s military. And it just so happens that I do not support the actions that the American government has been taking in foreign affairs. I also happen not to support the innocent bloodshed that has been caused by the American military’s actions in the middle east. Therefore, I do not support the individual American soldiers anymore than I support the war that they choose to contribute to. So often I see the “support the troops” bumper sticker on the back of a car (a lot of times it’s ironically on the back of an SUV or Hummer) right next to another sticker asking to End this War. Is anyone yet to sit down and actually think about that? The combination of those statements form an oxymoron. You simply can not support troops who are freely contributing to a war, while at the same time claiming to be against that very war. It seems as if a lot of people are trying to have it both ways, and it just doesn’t work like that. By supporting the troops, you are supporting the war. By opposing the war, you are opposing those who contribute to it. I really don’t believe that it’s as complicated of a concept as people make it out to be.
Every individual makes their own choices in life. This is a free country after all, and no one is forced to join it’s military. And those who are in the military choose whether to stay in it when times turn from peace to times of conflict. They choose whether to follow their orders or not. Yes, there would be negative consequences for someone in the military to go against what they are ordered. But it is still their free choice, none the less. If a man is told to kill people whom he does not know and who have done him no harm, and is given the choice between following those orders or facing time in prison, he must make that choice for himself. He is not to put blame on the organization who is giving the orders, when the man put himself under that organizations rule to begin with, fully knowing that he may be given such orders at some point in time.
I understand that not everyone who enlists in the military is a bad person. Most of them, I am sure, are really good people with great intentions in life. However, from my personal experience it is my opinion that many of those who sign up for the military simply could not think of anything more productive to do with their life. And/or they see it as a great way to escape their existing debt, unemployment and most of all, their uneventful life. As the ads claim, it gives people great confidence, job security, educational opportunities and even financial support for them and their families. What a deal. But at what cost? How many of those young people take the time to sit down and THINK, for themselves, about what exactly their role in the military is? Or about what the role of the military itself, is? And most of all, what exactly are the true intentions of America’s government? Many, I am willing to bet, don’t see much past the glamorous television ads. Or don’t want to. But then again, I have personally known one young soldier to admit that “he kind of wants to kill somebody.”
Not everyone in the military is like this, I know. However, the truth of the matter is that the military teaches young people how to kill. And how to do it with pride. Pride for “their country.” Plus they know that back home everybody and their grandmother is driving around in a gas guzzling SUV with a “Support the Troops” bumper sticker on the back of it.
Where will this road end? How far will this propaganda spread, and how long will it continue? It seems to me that the biggest crisis in this country may not be a corrupt government, or even global warming, but rather the great state of apathy shared by it’s citizens, young and old alike. Everybody goes along with supporting the troops, if for no other reason, because they never bothered to really care about it one way or the other. Its a lot easier to go along with something than to stand up and go against the grain. That might actually involve having to think, and might even mean not fitting in with everyone else (perish the thought!).
It’s so much easier to consider ourselves up to speed on current events when we are able to discuss the meaningless stories broadcasted by our local evening news. So much easier to obsess over sports, celebrities, and automobiles. So much easier to let yourself be consumed by the daily issues of your own personal life. As the saying goes, ignorance is bliss.
If you want to support the troops, then that’s fine with me. Go for it. All I ask is that you don’t expect me, and everyone else, to get on the bandwagon with you.
Thanks, and have a nice day.
Post Scriptum: While writing this, I couldn’t stop thinking about another example of propaganda that is often tied in with the “support the troops” slogan, which is the statement that the troops are “fighting for our freedom.” This does not make any logical sense to me, as I can not see how the bloodshed in the middle east has any effect whatsoever on the daily life of the American citizen, and certainly not on the quality of our “freedom.” Well, perhaps it does help fuel prices stay low.
Or perhaps that is just conspiracy. But I suppose that that would be a great incentive to all the consumers in their Hummers (which, by the way, are truly no more than glorifications of war). And even more of an incentive to those who market such ridiculously unnecessary vehicles. However, I won’t go any further with this line of thought, as I believe the effect of oil prices and America’s grim obsession with oversized, emotionally compensating vehicles really deserve a blog of its own. Or perhaps, maybe a whole book. I recommend reading Christopher Steiner’s “$20 a gallon” for insights on these particular topics.
***Constructive criticism on my writing is welcomed. Comments made in argument of my viewpoint will not be welcomed, as this is not an open invitation to debate. Please express your own viewpoints in your own blog. If you like, you are welcome send me the link to your blog after having done so.
Thank you.